Health & Medical Question

For this week’s discussion, you are asked to research a bioterrorist disaster. Begin by reviewing the content of this week’s module, then research for a bioterrorist disaster. Be sure you have chosen a biological agent, not a chemical agent (see the textbook for assistance).

Give an example and details from a bioterrorist attack. (You can use any bioterrorist attack except for the 2001 Anthrax attacks in the US).

Address all of the following in your post:

What was the classification of biological agent used in the attack? (Categories A, B, and C; see the textbook for assistance)

Discuss the implications or clinical manifestations of the biological agent chosen.

Discuss the therapy for the biological agent.

What are the decontamination procedures (for person exposed) for the biological agent used in the attack?

Per FEMA: Emergency vs. Disaster

P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
About the Editor
Tener Goodwin Veenema, PhD, MPH, MS, CPNP,
is an Associate Professor of Clinical Nursing, Assistant
Professor of Emergency Medicine, and Program Director
for Disaster Nursing and Strategic Initiatives at the Center for Disaster Medicine and Emergency Preparedness
at the University of Rochester School of Nursing and
School of Medicine and Dentistry. Dr. Veenema is also
President and Chief Executive Officer of the TenER Consulting Group, LLC, which provides consultation and
workforce development for emergency preparedness to
federal, state agencies, and corporate organizations. She
has received numerous awards and research grants for
her work, and in June 2004, Dr. Veenema was elected
into the National Academies of Practice and was selected as a 2004 Robert Wood Johnson Executive Nurse
Fellow. In 2006, Dr. Veenema was the recipient of the
Klainer Entrepreneurial Award in health care.
Dr. Veenema received her Bachelor of Science degree in Nursing from Columbia University in 1980 and
went on to obtain a Master of Science in Nursing Administration (1992) and a Master in Public Health (1999)
from the University of Rochester School of Medicine
and Dentistry. In 2001, she earned a PhD in Health Services Research and Policy from the same institution.
Dr. Veenema is a nationally certified Pediatric Nurse
Practitioner, and worked for many years in the Pediatric Emergency Department at Strong Memorial Hospital (Rochester, New York).
A highly successful author and editor, Dr. Veenema has published books and multiple articles on
emergency nursing and disaster preparedness. The first
edition of this textbook, published in August 2003, received an American Journal of Nursing Book-of-the-Year
Award.
Dr. Tener Goodwin Veenema, in her role as Chief Executive Officer of the TenER Consulting Group, LLC, is
the author and developer of “ReadyRN: A Comprehensive Curriculum for Disaster Nursing and Emergency
ii
Preparedness” and collaborated with the American Red
Cross to customize the ReadyRN curriculum for use
by the American Red Cross in educating and training
American Red Cross health care professionals in providing health-related disaster and emergency response
services.
Dr.Veenema’s ReadyRN Comprehensive Curriculum
for Disaster Nursing and Emergency Preparedness was
also published in 2007 as an innovative e-learning online
course by Elsevier, and the companion ReadyRN Handbook for Disaster Nursing and Emergency Preparedness
will be published in fall 2007.
While at the University of Rochester, Dr. Veenema
developed the curriculum for a 30-credit Masters program entitled “Leadership in Health Care Systems: Disaster Response and Emergency Management,” the first
program of its kind in the country to be offered at a
school of nursing. The program offers course content
on the Fundamentals of Disaster Management, Chemical, Biological and Radiological Terrorism, Global Public
Health and Complex Human Emergencies, Leadership
and Strategic Decision Making, and Communication in
Disaster Response and Emergency Preparedness.
Dr. Veenema has served as a reviewer to the Institute of Medicine Committee on the Review Panel for
the Smallpox Vaccination Implementation, Jane’s ChemBio Handbook, 2nd Edition, and serves on the editorial board for the journal Disaster Management and
Response, sponsored by the Emergency Nurses Association. Dr. Veenema is an Associate Editor for the Journal
of Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness,
sponsored by the American Medical Association.
Dr. Veenema frequently serves as a subject-matter
expert for the National American Red Cross, multiple
state health departments and nurses associations, as
well as the Registered Nurses Association of Ontario,
Canada. She is a member of the World Association of
Disaster Medicine (WADEM).
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Disaster
Nursing and
Emergency
Preparedness
for Chemical, Biological, and Radiological Terrorism
and Other Hazards
Second Edition
EDITOR
Tener Goodwin Veenema, PhD, MPH, MS, CPNP
iii
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
C 2007 Springer Publishing Company, LLC
Copyright 
All rights reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying,
recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Springer Publishing
Company, LLC.
Springer Publishing Company, LLC
11 West 42nd Street
New York, NY 10036–8002
www.springerpub.com
Acquisitions Editor: Sally J. Barhydt
Production Editor: Matthew Byrd
Cover Design: Mimi Flow
Composition: Aptara
07
08
09
10/
5
4 3 2 1
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Disaster nursing and emergency preparedness for chemical, biological, and radiological
terrorism and other hazards / Tener Goodwin Veenema. – 2nd ed.
p. ; cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN-13: 978-0-8261-2144-8
ISBN-10: 0-8261-2144-6
1. Disaster nursing. 2. Emergency nursing. I. Veenema, Tener Goodwin.
[DNLM: 1. Disasters. 2. Emergency Nursing. 3. Terrorism. WY 154 D6109 2007]
RT108.D56 2007
616.02 5–dc22
2007012380
Printed in the United States of America by Bang Printing
iv
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Preface
It is quite probable that at some time in the future, nurses
may be called upon to respond to a mass casualty event
or disaster outside of the hospital. Advance preparation
of our national nursing workforce for such an event is
predicted on the belief that mastery of the knowledge and
skills needed to respond appropriately to such an event
can improve patient outcomes.
I wrote these words in the spring of 2002 as I finished the summary section of chapter 9 (p. 199) in the
first edition of this book—3 1/2 years before Hurricane
Katrina would wreak its devastation on the communities of the Gulf Coast. When the first edition of the
book was released, our country was still reeling from the
9/11 attacks and fearful of another outbreak of anthrax.
These two events had resulted in an immediate awareness of our lack of national emergency preparedness and
heightened vulnerability to disaster events. Health care
providers were barraged by an onslaught of information
from numerous sources (of varying quality) regarding
topics such as disaster planning and response, biological agents, hazardous materials accidents, the dangers
of radiation, therapeutics, and so forth. Resources on
the Internet alone had increased exponentially. My own
research on these topics had revealed that the existing
disaster textbooks were written by and for physicians
and public health officials. There was a major gap in the
literature for nurses. Given the approximately 2.7 million nurses in this country, I found this to be not only
unacceptable but a major threat to population health
outcomes. Therefore, the genesis of the book was the desire to fill this gap in the literature and to provide nurses
with a comprehensive resource that was evidence based
whenever possible, and broad in scope and deep in detail. We were very successful and the first edition was extremely well received, garnering an AJN Book of the Year
award along with multiple additional accolades, and for
that I am eternally grateful. The book is currently being
used nationwide by universities and schools of nursing,
hospitals, public health departments, and multiple other
sites where nurses work.
The second edition of this textbook has an equally
ambitious goal—to once again provide nurses and nurse
practitioners with the most current, valid, and reliable
information available for them to acquire the knowledge
and skill set they will need to keep themselves, their patients, and families safe during any disaster event. Once
again, we have held ourselves to the highest standards
possible. Every chapter in the book has been researched,
reviewed by experts, and matched to the highest standards for preparing health professions’ students for terrorism, disaster events, and public health emergencies.
The framework of the book is consistent with the
United States National Response Plan, the National Incident Management System, and is based on the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) Competencies for public health preparedness and the CDC
Guidelines for response to chemical, biological, and radiological events. This textbook will provide nurses with
a heightened awareness for disasters and mass casualty
incidents, a solid foundation of knowledge (educational
competencies) and a tool box of skills (occupational
competencies) to respond in a timely and appropriate
manner.
Since September 11, 2001, our national concerns for
the health and safety of our citizens has expanded to
include additional hazards such as emerging infectious
diseases (SARS, West Nile virus, avian influenza), the
detonation of major explosive devices, and the use of
nuclear weapons by countries unfriendly to the United
States. We possess a heightened awareness of the forces
of Mother Nature and the health impact on communities affected by natural disasters. We continue to face a
growing national shortage of nurses and nurse educators, a health care system that is severely stressed financially, and emergency departments that are functioning
in disaster mode on a daily basis. We have reason to believe that these challenges for the profession will only
intensify in the coming years. Nurses are challenged to
be prepared for all hazards—to plan for pandemic influenza, chemical, biological, radiological/nuclear, and
explosive (CBRNE) events, mass casualty incidents involving major burns, and surge capacity to accommodate a sudden influx of hundreds, possibly thousands, of
patients. In response to these concerns and the requests
of nurses across the country, I have added several new
chapters in the second edition that serve to strengthen
the health systems focus of the book and to add a strong
clinical presence.
v
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
vi
May 17, 2007
Preface
Since 2003, the Department of Homeland Security,
the Federal Emergency Management Administration
(FEMA), the CDC, and other federal and nonfederal
agencies have devoted significant resources to increasing our level of national emergency preparedness. We
had made significant progress on certain fronts, but with
regard to our level of workforce preparedness in the
health professions, we have a long way to go. In the
years since the first edition of this textbook was published, other nursing texts and educational resources
have been developed and published, and this author applauds these initiatives. There is much work to be done,
and it is personally rewarding to witness increased interest in disaster nursing as more nurses get involved.
As an emergency nurse and pediatric nurse practitioner, I have worked in the field of disaster nursing and
emergency preparedness for many years, with a focus on
promoting the health of the community and the health
of the consumer by structuring, developing, and fostering an environment that is prepared for any disaster or
major public health emergency. I have lobbied for the
advancement of the profession of nursing in the disaster policy and education arena, and I remain personally
committed to my work in preparing a national nursing workforce that is adequately prepared to respond to
any disaster or public health emergency. This includes
working to establish sustainable community partnerships that foster collaboration and mutual planning for
the health of our community. It includes looking at innovative applications of technology to enhance sustainable
learning and disaster nursing response. It means giving
reflective consideration of the realities of the clinical demands placed on nurses during catastrophic events and
the need for consideration of altered standards for clinical care during disasters and public health emergencies.
This textbook continues to be a reflection of my
love for writing and research, as well as a deep desire to
help nurses protect themselves, their families, and their
communities. Disaster nursing is a patient safety issue.
Nurses can only protect their patients if they themselves are safe first. The second edition represents a
substantive attempt to collect, expand, update, and include the most valid and reliable information currently
available about various disasters, public health emergencies, and acts of terrorism. The target audience for
the book is every nurse in America—making every nurse
a prepared nurse—staff nurses, nurse practitioners, educators, and administrators. The scope of the book is
broad and the depth of detail intricate. My goal is to produce a second edition that represents a well-researched
and well-organized scholarly work that will serve as a
major reference for all our nation’s nurses on the topics of disaster nursing and emergency preparedness. It is
my hope that nurse educators will be pleased to discover
the expanded organization of the book and the inclusion
of new chapters, case studies, and study questions. The
insertion of Internet-based activities is designed to stimulate critical thinking in students and to provide them
with the skill set to stay updated regarding these topics.
Ideally, this book represents the foundation for best
practice in disaster nursing and emergency preparedness,
and is a stepping stone for the discipline of disaster nursing research. Chapters in this book were based on empirical evidence whenever it was available. However,
the amount of research in existence addressing disaster
nursing and health outcomes is limited, and much work
remains to be done. The editor welcomes constructive
comments regarding the content of this text.
Tener Goodwin Veenema
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Acknowledgments
As with the first edition of this book, I continue to profess that researching, revising, designing, and delivering this book was a true labor of love—I enjoyed every
minute of it! And like any effective disaster response,
this textbook was a coordinated team effort. The second
edition is significantly larger than the first—several new
chapters have been added, all of the content updated,
and the clinical focus expanded. Additionally, the entire book has been mapped to the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention’s competencies for public health
emergency preparedness—this represents nothing less
than a Herculean effort. There are so many exceptional
individuals, all over the country, who helped to make
this book a reality.
My special thanks must first go to each of the wonderful chapter authors who researched, reviewed, and
revised their manuscripts, assuring that the information
contained within was valid, accurate, and reliable, and
reflected the most current state of the science. This was
a tremendous challenge given the highly transitional nature of many of the topic areas. The science was rapidly
evolving (and continues to evolve) and as with the first
edition, the structure of many disaster and emergency
response systems was rapidly changing (and continues
to change) during the year it was written.
I would like to first thank my fabulous colleagues
who were chapter authors and/or contributors for the
first edition and stayed committed to this project for the
second edition. My very sincere thanks go to Kathleen
Coyne Plum, PhD, RN, NPP (Monroe County Department of Human Services); Kristine Qureshi, RN, CEN,
DNSc (University of Hawaii); Brigitte L. Nacos, PhD and
Kristine M. Gebbie, DrPH, RN, FAAN (Columbia University); Lisa Marie Bernardo, RN, PhD, MPH (University
of Pittsburgh); Erica Rihl Pryor, RN, PhD and Dave Pigott, MD, FACEP (University of Alabama); Linda Landesman, DrPH, MSW, ACSW, LCSW, BCD (NYC Health &
Hospitals Consortium); Kathryn McCabe Votava, PhD,
RN and Cathy Peters, MS, RN, APRN-BC (University of
Rochester); P. Andrew Karam, PhD, CHP (MJW Corporation); Joan Stanley, PhD, RN, CRNP (American
Association of Colleges of Nursing); Lt. Col. Richard
Ricciardi, RN, FNP and Patricia Hinton Walker, PhD,
RN, FAAN (Uniformed Services University of the Health
Services); Janice B. Griffin Agazio, PhD, CRNP, RN
(The Catholic University of America); Eric Croddy, MA
(Monterey Institute for International Studies); and Gary
Ackerman, MA (Center for Terrorism and Intelligence
Studies). Thank you so much for your wonderful contributions and for your ongoing support of this book.
Very special acknowledgments and many thanks
go to my international colleagues at the University of
Ulster—Pat Deeny, Kevin Davies, and Mark Gillespie,
and welcome to Wendy Spencer. These wonderful individuals were committed to providing a broad and illustrative international perspective for the book. Their
resultant chapter, Global Issues in Disaster Relief Nursing, is evidence of their expert knowledge, extensive
experience in the field, and dedication to international
collegiality. I will always remain grateful to each of them
for their contributions to the field.
My thanks go once again to Jonathan Tucker, my
special contributor, for allowing me to reprint a portion
of his work from his wonderful book Scourge: The Once
and Future Threat of Smallpox. It continues to be the
perfect segue into the Chemical and Biological Terrorism
section of the book.
I wish to thank each of the case study authors and
welcome the following new authors to the second edition of the book. Thanks go to Ziad N. Kazzi, MD,
FAAEM, along with his colleagues Dave Pigott, MD,
FACEP and Erica Pryor, RN, PhD at the University of Alabama at Birmingham Center for Disaster Preparedness.
The quality of their work is incredible, as is their generosity in sharing it.
Another very special welcome and thanks go to
Roberta Lavin (Health and Human Services) and Lynn
Slepski (Department of Homeland Security). Roberta
and Lynn made sure that the descriptions of the National Response Plan and all components of the federal
disaster program were as accurate as possible up to the
time of publication. They are also two of the nicest and
most generous individuals one would ever want to meet.
Welcome and thanks go to Christopher Lentz, MD,
FACS, FCCM; Dixie Reid, PA; Brooke Rea, MS, RN; and
Kerry Kehoe, MS (University of Rochester) for their
chapter addressing the recognition and management of
burns and guidelines for disaster planning for a surge of
vii
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
viii
May 17, 2007
Acknowledgments
burn patients. Dr. Lentz, as the Director of the regional
Burn/Trauma Center at the University of Rochester Medical Center, along with his wife Dixie Reid, are burn
experts and tireless advocates for clinical excellence in
the care of the severely burned patient. Both Brooke Rea
(Burn Program Manager) and Kerry Kehoe (former Administrator Division of Trauma & Burn) are graduates of
the Leadership in Health Care Systems in Disaster Response and Emergency Health Care Systems, and so it
is an even greater pleasure to be able to include them in
this edition of the book. Brooke’s talents and leadership
skills were clearly evident in her effort to produce this
chapter, and I send her my special thanks.
A sincere welcome and thanks go out to two new
authors and former students of mine, Tara Sacco, MS,
BS, RN and Jennifer Byrnes, MLS, MPH (University
of Rochester). Tara is a graduate of the Leadership in
Health Care Systems program in Health Promotion and
Health Education; Jennifer is a graduate of the Master’s in Public Health program. Both are talented researchers and writers, and it is my guess that you will
be hearing more from them in the future. Their chapters
on Traumatic Injuries Due to Explosions and Blast Effects, and Emerging Infectious Diseases (respectively)
broadly expanded the clinical focus of the book and
provided valuable new clinical resource information for
nurses.
Welcome and thanks go to Amy T. Campbell, JD,
MBE (University of Rochester, Division of Medical Humanities) for her detailed legal review and update of the
chapter on Legal and Ethical Issues in Disaster Response
and to Joy Spellman (Burlington County College, New
Jersey) for her contributions on preparing and promoting the role of the public health nurses during disasters.
Both of these authors were so gracious and generous
with their expertise. Thank you.
A very special warm welcome and thanks go to
Elizabeth A. Davis, JD, Ed.M and her colleagues Alan
Clive, PhD, Jane A. Kushma, PhD, and Jennifer Mincin,
MPA. Elizabeth is the Founder and President of Elizabeth Ann Davis Associates (http://www.eadassociates.
com/) and is a nationally recognized expert/advocate
for vulnerable populations. It was extremely important
to me to add a substantive piece on planning for and
responding to the needs of high-risk, high-vulnerability
populations in this edition of the book, and Alan, Elizabeth, Jane, and Jennifer provided a superb chapter on
this topic (and in a relatively short time frame). My sincere thanks and admiration go out to each of you for
your work.
Welcome and gratitude go to Manish Shah, MD,
MPH, FACEP; Jeremy Cushman, MD, MS; Charles Maddow, MD, FACEP; and Jonnathan Busko, MD, MPH,
EMT-P (University of Rochester, Department of Emergency Medicine), and to my colleague John Benitez,
MD, MPH at the Center for Disaster Medicine and
Emergency Preparedness (University of Rochester, Department of Emergency Medicine). Manish Shah, along
with his colleagues Jeremy, Charles, and Jonnathan,
contributed a comprehensive overview of Emergency
Medical Services as it currently exists in this country.
This well-designed and well-organized chapter was a
wonderful new addition to the book. John Benitez is
Director of the Western New York Regional Poison Control Center, who along with Sharon Benware, RN, contributed to the chapter addressing chemical agents of
concern.
I want to express my continued appreciation and
sincere gratitude to Lisa Bernardo, Erica Pryor, Kristine Qureshi, and Kathy Plum for their elegant contributions, for their ongoing support and encouragement,
and for their willingness to make recommendations that
strengthened the content of the book. I have the ultimate
respect for each of you, and I am sincerely grateful for
our ongoing relationships!
Special thanks go out to my wonderful friends and
colleagues, Diane Yeater, Associate Director for Disaster
Health Services and to Nancy McKelvey, Chief Nurse
at the American Red Cross, National Headquarters in
Washington, DC. Thank you for your contributions and
your insight into national disaster preparedness and response initiatives.
I am so fortunate to call the University of Rochester
School of Nursing my academic home. This phenomenal school is a leader in excellence in nursing education and in entrepreneurship for nurses, and I have
learned something from every one of my talented colleagues. I wish to once again thank Dean Patricia Chiverton for creating an environment that supports new and
visionary initiatives and for supporting and encouraging me to do the work that I want to do. I am eternally
grateful to Pat and to each of my fellow faculty members in the Leadership in Health Care Systems Master’s
Program.
As I finish the second edition of this book, I would
also like to acknowledge 19 wonderfully talented individuals and very special, terrific friends—my colleagues in the 2004 Robert Wood Johnson Executive Nurse Fellowship: Carla Baumann, Suzanne Boyle,
Kathleen Capitulo, June Chan, Theresa Daggi, Kathryn
Fiandt, Margaret Frankhauser, Mary Hooshmand, Paul
Kuehnert, Mary Joan Ladden, Joan Marren, Marcia
Maurer, Marcella McKay, Wanda Montalvo, Kathleen
Murphy, Cheri Rinehart, Mary Lou de Leon Siantz,
Kristen Swanson, and Bonnie Westra. We have shared
an amazing experience in this wonderful program, and
they have provided me with insight and guidance for
my work, of which this book represents a portion of the
overall project—ReadyRN: Making Every Nurse a Prepared Nurse. Their incredible work inspired me. But
mostly I am grateful for the fun, friendship, and support they offered. They believed in my vision for disaster
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Acknowledgments
nursing and for this book, and they are always there for
me when I need them. Thank you.
Special thanks to Loretta Ford, former Dean and Professor Emeritus at the University of Rochester School of
Nursing, and founder of the nurse practitioner role. I
have had the amazing good fortune of having Lee as my
mentor in the Robert Wood Johnson Executive Nurse
Fellowship Program. There are no words to describe
this feisty, energetic, phenomenally talented nurse and
scholar. She is a role model to the entire profession of
nursing, and my life is richer for having known her.
Her wisdom and guidance have played a pivotal role in
much of my work the past few years. Her kindness and
support have sustained me. Thank you so much Lee.
I wish to thank all of my reviewers and those who
provided valued commentary and recommendations.
Special thanks to Lori Barrette (University of Rochester),
Janice Springer (American Red Cross), and Lou Romig,
MD, FAAP, FACEP. Just as there is no perfect research
study, there is also not a perfect textbook or reference
manual. This fact, however, did not dissuade us from
seeking to make this book and every section in it the
very best it could be. Many thanks to all who shared
their wisdom and expertise during the preparation of
the book.
I would like to acknowledge Sally Barhydt and her
colleagues at Springer Publishing Company in New York
City. I sincerely thank you, Sally, for all your hard work
in assisting with the publication of the second edition,
and for your ongoing commitment to me as an author.
ix
I will be eternally grateful to my colleague and research assistant Adam B. Rains for his assistance with
the preparation of this very large manuscript. Adam’s intelligence, humor and wit—and limitless talent—were a
gift to this project.
Many thanks go to three very special women who
are the best friends anyone could ask for—Katherine
Lostumbo, Barbara Wale, and Maryanne Townsend. The
warmth of your friendship continues to sustain me.
Finally, the people to whom I owe the most are my
family. To my mother, thank you for all you have done
for me and for thinking that I am much more capable
than I really am. You often told me, “to thine own self
be true,” when making my life’s decisions—great advice
that I have often passed down to my children. Thanks
to my dad—I love you lots.
To my four children, I sincerely thank you for the
joy you have brought to my life. You are my greatest
accomplishment. My sons Kyle, Blair, and Ryne—I love
you so much. A huge and especially special thank you
goes to my wonderful daughter Kendall, who has been
a terrific help to me for many, many years. Her words
of encouragement (and the sound of her laughter) have
always kept me going! She is my very best friend and
the most incredible person I know.
And to my husband and partner in all life’s adventures, my deepest thanks. I could not have done any of
this without you. You have helped me in too many ways
to mention, and I am so appreciative of each and every
moment we have shared. Thank you.
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
x
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Contributors
Gary Ackerman, MA
Sharon Benware, RN, CSPI
Director
Center for Terrorism and Intelligence Studies
A Division of the Akribis Group
San Jose, California
RA Lawrence Poison and Drug Information Center
Rochester, New York
Janice B. Griffin Agazio, PhD, CRNP, RN
Assistant Professor
The Catholic University of America
School of Nursing
Washington, DC
Sherri-Lynne Almeida, DrPH, MSN, Med, RN, CEN
Chief Operating Officer—Team Health Southwest
Houston, Texas
Knox Andress, RN, FAEN
Designated Regional Coordinator
Louisiana Region 7 Hospital Preparedness
Director of Emergency Preparedness
Louisiana Poison Center
Shreveport, Louisiana
Randal D. Beaton, PhD, EMT
Research Professor
Department of Psychosocial and Community
Health
School of Nursing
Adjunct Research Professor
Department of Health Services
School of Public Health and Community Medicine
University of Washington
Seattle, Washington
Lisa Marie Bernardo, RN, PhD, MPH
Associate Professor
University of Pittsburgh School of Nursing
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Jonnathan Busko, MD, MPH, EMT-P
Emergency Physician / Medical Director,
Operations
Eastern Maine Medical Center
Bangor, Maine
Regional Medical Director, Maine EMS
Region 4
Medical Director, Maine Medical Strike Team
New England MMRS
Medical Director, Northeastern Maine Regional
Resource Center and
Center for Emergency Preparedness
Eastern Maine Healthcare System
Jennifer A. Byrnes, MLS, MPH
University of Rochester School of Medicine
and Dentistry
Rochester, New York
Amy T. Campbell, JD, MBE
Division of Medical Humanities
University of Rochester Medical Center
Rochester, New York
John G. Benitez, MD, MPH
Alan Clive, PhD
Associate Professor of Emergency Medicine,
Environmental Medicine and Pediatrics
University of Rochester School of Medicine and
Dentistry
Director, Finger Lakes Regional Resource Center
Managing and Associate Medical Director
RA Lawrence Poison and Drug Information Center
Rochester, New York
Emergency Management Consultant
Silver Spring, Maryland
Eric Croddy, MA
Senior Research Associate
Monterey Institute of International Studies
Center for Nonproliferation Studies
Monterey, California
xi
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
xii
May 17, 2007
Contributors
Jeremy T. Cushman, MD, MS
P. Andrew Karam, PhD, CHP
Division of EMS and Office of Prehospital
Care
Department of Emergency Medicine
University of Rochester School of Medicine and
Dentistry
Rochester, New York
Senior Health Physicist
MJW Corporation
Rochester, New York
Kevin Davies, RRC, RN, MA, RNT, PGCE
Senior Lecturer in Nursing
School of Care Sciences
University of Glamorgan
Pontypridd, South Wales, United Kingdom
Elizabeth A. Davis, JD, Ed.M
Director
EAD & Associates, LLC
Emergency Management & Special Needs Consultants
New York, New York
Pat Deeny, RN, RNT, BSc (Hons) Nursing
Ad Dip Ed.
Senior Lecturer in Nursing
University of Ulster, Magee Campus
Derry-Londonderry, Northern Ireland
Mary Kate Dilts Skaggs, RN, MSN
Director of Nursing Emergency Services
Southern Ohio Medical Center
Portsmouth, Ohio
Kristine M. Gebbie, DrPH, RN, FAAN
Elizabeth Standish Gill Associate Professor
Columbia University School of Nursing
Center for Health Policy
New York, New York
Mark Gillespie, RN, MSc
Advanced Nursing, Critical Nurse Specialist
Lecturer Trauma Nursing
University of Ulster, Magee
Derry-Londonberry, Northern Ireland
Ziad N. Kazzi, MD, FAAEM
Assistant Professor
Medical Toxicologist
Department of Emergency Medicine
University of Alabama
Birmingham, Alabama
Kerry Kehoe, MS
Administrator, Division of Trauma, Burn &
Emergency Surgery
University of Rochester Medical Center
Rochester, New York
Paul Kuehnert, MS, RN
Deputy Director
Kane County Department of Health
Aurora, Illinois
Jane A. Kushma, PhD
Associate Professor
Institute for Emergency Preparedness
Jacksonville State University
Jacksonville, Alabama
Linda Young Landesman, DrPH, MSW, ACSW,
LCSW, BCD
NYC Health and Hospitals Corporation
New York, New York
Roberta Proffitt Lavin, MSN, APRN, BC
CAPT, United States Public Health Service
Director, Office of Human Services Emergency
Preparedness and Response
Administration for Children and Families
Department of Health and Human Services
Washington, DC
Christopher W. Lentz, MD, FACS, FCCM
Kevin D. Hart, JD, PhD
Assistant Professor
Department of Community and Preventative
Medicine
University of Rochester School of Medicine
and Dentistry
Rochester, New York
Medical Director, Strong Regional Burn Center
Associate Professor of Surgery and
Pediatrics
University of Rochester School of Medicine and
Dentistry
Rochester, New York
Charles L. Maddow, MD, FACEP
Angela J. Hodge, RN, BSN, CEN
Clinical Coordinator for Emergency Services
Southern Ohio Medical Center
Portsmouth, Ohio
Department of Emergency Medicine
University of Rochester School of Medicine and
Dentistry
Rochester, New York
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Contributors
Nancy McKelvey, MSN, RN
Kristine Qureshi, RN, CEN, DNSc
Chief Nurse/Healthcare Partnerships Lead
American Red Cross
Washington, DC
Associate Professor
School of Nursing and Dental Hygiene
University of Hawaii at Manoa
Honolulu, Hawaii
Jennifer Mincin, MPA
Senior Project Manager
EAD & Associates, LLC
Emergency Management & Special Needs Consultants
New York, New York
Brigitte L. Nacos, PhD
Department of Political Science
Columbia University
New York, New York
Karen Nason
Executive Director
Association of Rehabilitation Nurses
Rehabilitation Nursing Certification Board
Sally A. Norton, PhD, RN
Assistant Professor of Nursing
University of Rochester School of Nursing
Rochester, New York
Cathy Peters, MS, RN, APRN-BC
Assistant Clinical Professor
University of Rochester School of Nursing
Assistant Clinical Professor, Adjunct Faculty
Division of Medical Humanities
University of Rochester School of
Medicine
Rochester, New York
David C. Pigott, MD, FACEP
Residency Program Director
Associate Professor and Vice Chair for Education
Department of Emergency Medicine
University of Alabama at Birmingham
Birmingham, Alabama
xiii
Irwin Redlener, MD
Associate Dean & Director
The National Center for Disaster Preparedness
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health
New York, New York
Dixie Reid, PA
Physician Assistant
Trauma/Burn/Emergency Surgery
University of Rochester School of Medicine and
Dentistry
Rochester, New York
Brooke Rera, MS, RN
Burn Program Manager
University of Rochester/Strong Memorial Hospital
Rochester, New York
Lt. Col. Richard Ricciardi, RN, FNP
Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences
Graduate School of Nursing
Bethesda, Maryland
Lou E. Romig, MD, FAAP, FACEP
Pediatric Emergency Medicine
Miami Children’s Hospital
Pediatric Medical Advisor, Miami-Dade Fire Rescue
Department
South Florida Regional Disaster Medical Assistance
Team (FL-5 DMAT)
Miami, Florida
Tara Sacco, MS, BS, RN
Burn Trauma Unit
University of Rochester Medical Center
Rochester, New York
Kathleen Coyne Plum, PhD, RN, NPP
Manish N. Shah, MD, MPH, FACEP
Director, Office of Mental Health,
Monroe County Department of Human Services
Rochester, New York
Adjunct Associate Professor, University of Rochester
School of Nursing
Rochester, New York
Director, EMS Research
Assistant Professor
Department of Emergency Medicine
Department of Community and Preventive Medicine
University of Rochester School of Medicine and
Dentistry
Rochester, New York
Erica Rihl Pryor, RN, MSN, PhD
Doctoral Program Coordinator and Assistant Professor
University of Alabama School of Nursing
University of Alabama at Birmingham
Birmingham, Alabama
Capt. Lynn A. Slepski, RN, MSN, PhD-C, CCNS
Senior Public Health Advisor
Department of Homeland Security
Washington, DC
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
xiv
May 17, 2007
Contributors
Joy Spellman, MS, RN
Jennifer Timony
Director, Center for Public Health Preparedness
Burlington County College
Mt. Laurel, New Jersey
President
National Student Nurses’ Association, Inc.
Wendy Spencer
President
GoodCare.com
Washington, DC
University of Ulster
Janice Springer, RN, PHN, MA
Disaster Health Services
American Red Cross
Washington, DC
Joan M. Stanley, PhD, RN, CRNP
Director of Education Policy
American Association of Colleges of
Nursing
Washington, DC
Kathryn McCabe Votava, PhD, RN
Patricia Hinton Walker, PhD, RN, FAAN
Vice President for Nursing Policy and Professor
Uniformed Services University of the
Health Sciences
Bethesda, Maryland
Dianne Yeater
Director for Disaster Health Services
American Red Cross
Washington, DC
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Dedication
Our world is not safe. Fraught with peril, it continues
to be a dangerous place in which to live. And yet we
know that our children need safe homes, safe schools,
and safe communities to live in if they are to grow to
be healthy, happy, and secure adults. They are counting
on us to be there for them—no matter what the circumstances. They are counting on us to provide love,
protection, and a safe harbor in the storm. They are
counting on us to be prepared. They are counting on us
to rescue them when they need rescuing. This textbook
is dedicated to our nation’s children—four in particular.
To Kyle, Kendall, Blair, and Ryne—you are everything to
me. Always know how much I love you and that home
is a safe harbor. And know that I tried to make the world
a safer place.
xv
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
xvi
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Foreword
Most doctors, nurses, and other health workers look forward to a life pursuing their chosen career in relative
order, peace, and tranquility. However, the unexpected,
by its very nature, can strike anywhere, at any time, and
involve anybody or everybody, including those who are
unprepared. A disaster can happen in any community
at any time. It is an inescapable fact brought into focus
by the calamitous events we have seen befall our fellow
citizens in just the past 5 years. From the four hurricanes that hit our coastal regions in just one 6-week
period in 2004 to the twin shocks of the South Asia
tsunami and Hurricane Katrina; earthquakes in Indonesia; floods; terrorist bombings in the London subway
and Iraq (an everyday phenomenon in Baghdad); and
a humanitarian crisis of unimaginable horror in Sudan,
it is clear that no community is immune. Nurses have
a primary role in preparing for and managing medical
care during these episodic, but catastrophic, events. On
a global scale, nurses are active participants in caring
for victims of a wide variety of disasters that take place
on an almost daily basis.
The second edition of Disaster Nursing and Emergency Preparedness for Chemical, Biological, and Radiological Terrorism and Other Hazards has been designed
to provide emergency caregivers with a concise reference for managing specific disaster-preparedness and
response issues while providing the prerequisite background necessary to begin an in-depth study of the
health consequences of the most common types of disasters. The experience of the editor and many of the
chapter authors is unique. The organizations for which
they work cover the range of disasters that strike this
world. We owe an enormous debt of gratitude to them
all for their unstinting efforts to update this classic work.
Postdisaster evaluations conducted by nurses of the
management of disasters by health professionals have
provided critical data for mitigating the human impact
of these events and enhancing future responses to disasters. This has been especially true regarding Hurricane
Katrina. As a result, disaster management is well recognized as far more than just triage and mass casualty management. Since the first edition of this book
was published, we have seen significant changes in
the health management of disasters, whether natural
or man-made. It is increasingly appreciated that the
phenomenon goes far beyond the punctual provision
of relief to the population affected and extends from
advanced preparedness to the problems of long-term
rehabilitation. While always emphasizing the use of
proven management methods and practices, Dr. Veenema challenges nursing health professionals with questions that must still be answered in order for them to
respond effectively in emergency situations. I know that
decision makers at the highest echelons of government
have increasingly relied on the nursing profession to
address the myriad problems facing a disaster-affected
community.
In the relatively short period of time that has elapsed
since September 11, 2001, it is remarkable that a considerable body of new knowledge and experience related
to the adverse health effects of disasters has already accumulated. In fact, disaster research has accelerated to
such an extent that we probably need to update the results of this research at a minimum of every year so that
we can apply the lessons learned during one disaster to
the management of the next. Conveying so much information in so few pages, with the right mix of scientific
data and human concern, in a practical and clear format, is no mean task. As the most comprehensive textbook on disaster nursing ever published (except for the
groundbreaking first edition published in 2003), Disaster Nursing and Emergency Preparedness for Chemical,
Biological, and Radiological Terrorism and Other Hazards does exactly that and more. With years of experience, Dr. Veenema and co-authors give the reader ample
technical descriptions of each kind of disaster (particularly chemical, biological, radiological terrorism, and
other hazards), an examination of the kinds of issues
and problems that arise in planning hospital and emergency department disaster response, and an up-to-date
review of the more common medical and management
issues that might face a nurse involved in a local disaster. Unique chapters include those addressing the legal
and ethical issues in disaster response, the role of the
media, effective communication with the public (a major deficiency during Hurricane Katrina and the South
Asia tsunami), the special needs of children during disasters and public health emergencies, and the evolving
xvii
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
xviii
May 17, 2007
Foreword
priorities of the Departments of Health and Human Services and Homeland Security.
Like the first edition, the second edition includes
well-designed case studies that provide realistic, handson experiences that challenge the reader to apply information provided in the chapters. Dr. Veenema’s inclusion of “Key Messages” and “Learning Objectives” that
introduce each major section of the book, plus unique
case studies addressing natural, industrial, and terrorism disasters, has resulted in the creation of a major resource that will serve as a timely, comprehensive, and
structured text for the education of hospital, community,
state, and national health and medical emergency managers, as well as nursing students who will assume major mass emergency preparedness responsibilities immediately after graduation.
It is incumbent that all health care workers, and
nurses in particular, react professionally, efficiently, rationally, and effectively when disaster strikes. To do so,
they need some fundamental principles and knowledge
on which to base their activities. This highly topical
book will serve as the most up-to-date course textbook
and desk reference available not only for nursing professionals responsible for preparing their hospitals for
responding to disasters and other public health emergencies but also for emergency managers and other decision makers charged with ensuring that disasters are
well managed.
Eric K. Noji, MD, MPH, FACEP
Program Director
Pandemic Avian Influenza Preparedness
Program
Global Epidemic Intelligence Network
Center for Disaster Medicine & Humanitarian
Assistance
Department of Military & Emergency Medicine
Uniformed Services University of the
Health Sciences
Bethesda, Maryland
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Foreword
In the years since the first edition of this book was published, the complexity of terrorism has continued to increase. We now are very aware that terrorists exist, not
only outside our country trying to get in, but also inside
our country in small towns and large cities where some
of our own citizens are plotting our downfall.
I have always said that nurses are the glue that holds
our health care delivery system (as fragmented as it is)
together. Once a nurse, always a nurse! Nurses in our
communities are also expected to be able to respond to
the natural and man-made disasters that we will surely
encounter in the next few years. Our response must be
evidence based, as is so well exemplified by these chapters. This text gathers together the best thoughts about
evidence-based response wherever possible and identifies where the evidence is spotty and slim.
As the founder of the International Nursing Coalition for Mass Casualty Education in March 2001
(now the Nursing Emergency Preparedness Education
Coalition), which now represents over 80 nursing organizations, friends of nursing, and subject matter experts,
I was not privy to any special vision. I knew that our
public health infrastructure was rickety—at best—and
that, in the event of any kind of mass casualty event,
nurses would be expected to be in the forefront. I also
knew that disaster nursing had virtually disappeared
from our curricula, although we still incorporated basic
population-based public health principles. If one good
thing comes out of the tragedy of 9/11, it will be that
monies granted from Congress to address terrorism will
serve a dual role and also help strengthen our public
health infrastructure.
The book you are about to read offers a comprehensive analysis of a broad range of disasters possible in today’s world—both those wreaked by humans as well as
by nature. This text is the next generation of information
needed by nurses to be informed about and responsive
to the needs of our citizens in a disaster. Katrina was a
wake-up event. The roles that nurses and nurse assistants played in that disaster were selfless and inspiring.
Katrina only served to undergird our awareness that we
must be vigilant and prepared!
Colleen Conway-Welch, PhD, RN, CNM, FAAN,
FACNM
Nancy & Hilliard Travis Professor of Nursing
Dean
Vanderbilt University School of Nursing
xix
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Special Foreword
As a Robert Wood Johnson Executive Nurse Fellow, Dr.
Veenema, a disaster nursing expert, chose to pursue
a lofty fellowship goal of “creating a national nursing
workforce adequately prepared to respond to a disaster
or any major public health emergency.” This monumental undertaking sounds and is formidable. Still, this second edition of her highly successful earlier publication,
Disaster Nursing, convinces me she is well on the way
toward that goal.
This expanded and updated edition is all encompassing and forms the basis for all her other efforts
in developing printware and software and educational
forums, coordinating and collaborating with volunteer
and governmental agencies, and encouraging educational and professional organizations to help prepare
nurses and other health professionals for natural and
man-made disasters. The breadth and depth of this publication are phenomenally comprehensive and practical as well as theoretically and scientifically sound. Its
xx
expanded scope ranges from preparedness and management to specific types of disasters, ending with
chapters on nursing education, research, and global
connections.
I would find this edition particularly useful for its
teaching/learning framework that focuses the learner
on goals and expected outcomes. Case studies expedite
discourse and critical thinking as do references and Internet sources.
In its expanded form and extensive content, this second edition is indeed required reading as a textbook, a
reference, a compendium of comprehensive topics, and
foundational to “making every nurse a prepared nurse.”
Loretta C. Ford, RN, PNP, EdD
Dean Emeritus
University of Rochester School of Nursing
Founder of the Nurse Practioner Program
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM
SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 18, 2007
Contents
About the Editor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ii
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xi
Dedication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv
Foreword (Eric K. Noji ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xvii
Foreword (Colleen Conway-Welch ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xix
Special Foreword (Loretta C. Ford ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xx
P A R T
I
DISASTER PREPAREDNESS
Chapter 1
Essentials of Disaster Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 2
Leadership and Coordination in Disaster Health Care Systems:
The Federal Disaster Response Network . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
Roberta Lavin, Lynn Slepski, and Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 3
Emergency Health Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51
Jeremy T. Cushman, Manish N. Shah, Charles L. Maddow, and Jonnathan Busko
Chapter 4
American Red Cross Disaster Health Services and Disaster Nursing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67
Dianne Yeater and Nancy McKelvey
Chapter 5
Understanding the Psychosocial Impact of Disasters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 81
Kathleen Coyne Plum
Chapter 6
Legal and Ethical Issues in Disaster Response . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101
Amy T. Campbell, Kevin D. Hart, and Sally A. Norton
Chapter 7
Crisis Communication: The Role of the Media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119
Brigitte L. Nacos
xxi
7:48
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
xxii
May 17, 2007
Contents
P A R T
I I
DISASTER MANAGEMENT
Chapter 8
Disaster Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137
Kristine Qureshi and Kristine M. Gebbie
Chapter 9
Disaster Triage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161
Kristine Qureshi and Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 10
Restoring Public Health Under Disaster Conditions: Basic Sanitation, Water
and Food Supply, and Shelter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179
Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 11
Managing Emergencies Outside of the Hospital: Special Events, Mass Gatherings,
and Mass Casualty Incidents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 205
Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 12
Management of Burn Mass Casualty Incidents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221
Christopher Lentz, Dixie Reid, Brooke Rera, and Kerry Kehoe
Chapter 13
Traumatic Injury Due to Explosives and Blast Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239
Tara Sacco
Chapter 14
Management of Psychosocial Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 255
Kathleen Coyne Plum and Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 15
Unique Needs of Children During Disasters and Other Public Health Emergencies . . . . 273
Lisa Marie Bernardo
Chapter 16
Identifying and Accommodating High-Risk and High-Vulnerability Populations . . . . . . . 309
Alan Clive, Elizabeth A. Davis, Jane A. Kushma, and Jennifer Mincin
P A R T
I I I
NATURAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTERS
Chapter 17
Natural Disasters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 327
Linda Young Landesman and Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 18
Environmental Disasters and Emergencies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 351
Tener Goodwin Veenema
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
May 17, 2007
Contents
P A R T
xxiii
I V
DISASTERS CAUSED BY CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, AND RADIOLOGICAL AGENTS
Chapter 19
Biological and Chemical Terrorism: A Unique Threat . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 365
Eric Croddy and Gary Ackerman
Chapter 20
Surveillance Systems for Detection of Biological Events . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 389
Erica Rihl Pryor
Chapter 21
Biological Agents of Concern . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 403
David C. Pigott and Ziad N. Kazzi
Chapter 22
Early Recognition and Detection of Biological Events . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 423
Erica Rihl Pryor
Chapter 23
Emerging Infectious Disease . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 437
Jennifer A. Byrnes
Chapter 24
Design and Implementation of Mass Immunization and Prophylactic
Treatment Clinics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 459
Kathryn McCabe Votava
Chapter 25
Chemical Agents of Concern . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 483
Tener Goodwin Veenema, John Benitez, and Sharon Benware
Chapter 26
Mass Casualty Decontamination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 505
Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 27
Radiological Incidents and Emergencies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 521
Andrew Karam
P A R T
V
SPECIAL TOPICS
Chapter 28
Directions for Nursing Education . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 545
Joan M. Stanley and Tener Goodwin Veenema
Chapter 29
Directions for Nursing Research and Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 559
Richard Ricciardi, Janice B. Griffin Agazio, Roberta P. Lavin, and
Patricia Hinton Walker
15:33
P1: JZP
SVNF026-FM SVNF026/Veenema-FM
xxiv
May 17, 2007
Contents
Chapter 30
Global Issues in Disaster Relief Nursing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 571
Pat Deeny, Kevin Davies, Mark Gillespie, and Wendy Spencer
Chapter 31
The Role and Preparation of the Public Health Nurse for Disaster Response . . . . . . . . . 589
Joy Spellman
Epilogue
Disaster Recovery: Creating Sustainable Disaster-Resistant Communities . . . . . . . . . . 601
Tener Goodwin Veenema
Appendices
I
Internet Resources on Disaster Preparedness, Emergency Care, and
Bioterrorism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 603
II
Glossary of Terms Commonly Used in Disaster Preparedness and
Response . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 607
III
Bioterrorism and Emergency Readiness: Competencies for All Public
Health Workers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 615
IV
Federal Emergency Management Agency: Emergency Response Action
Steps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 617
V
Anthrax Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 620
VI
Botulism Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 621
VII
Plague Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 622
VIII
Smallpox Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 623
IX
Tularemia Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 624
X
Viral Hemorrhagic Fevers Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 625
XI
Biological Weapon (BW) Agent Lab Identification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 626
XII
Patient Isolation Precautions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 630
XIII
Creating a Personal Disaster Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 632
INDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 637
15:33
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
P A R T
Disaster
Preparedness
1
I
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
Key Messages
■ The frequency of natural disasters, the individuals affected by them, and the eco-
nomic costs associated with loss have been steadily increasing over recent years.
■ While disasters are often unexpected, sound disaster planning can anticipate
common problems and mitigate the consequences of the event.
■ Different types of disasters are associated with distinct patterns of illness and
injury, and early assessment of risks and vulnerability can reduce morbidity and
mortality later on.
■ Effective disaster plans are based on knowledge of how people behave. Key components and common tasks must be included in any disaster preparedness plan.
■ The actual process of planning is more important than the resultant written plan
because those who participate in planning are more likely to accept preparedness
plans in general.
■ Disaster planning must overcome apathy and complacency.
■ Disasters are different from daily emergencies; most cannot be managed simply
by mobilizing additional personnel and supplies. Certain commonly occurring
problems can be anticipated and addressed during planning.
■ A professional mandate exists that calls for nurses to participate in the development of and serve as an integral part of a community’s disaster preparedness
plan.
■ Nurses must participate as full partners with both the medical community and
emergency management community in all aspects of disaster response and
recovery.
Learning Objectives
When this chapter is completed, readers will be able to
1. Classify the major types of disasters based on their unique characteristics and
describe their consequences.
2. Identify societal factors that have contributed to increased losses (human and
property) as the result of disasters.
3. Describe two principles of disaster planning, including the agent-specific and the
all-hazards approach, and the basic components of a disaster plan.
4. Discuss the five areas of focus in emergency and disaster planning: preparedness, mitigation, response, recovery, and evaluation.
5. Describe risk assessment, hazard identification, and vulnerability analysis.
6. Assess constraints on a community’s or organization’s ability to respond.
7. Describe the core preparedness actions.
8. Recognize situations suggestive of an increased need for additional comprehensive planning.
2
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
1
Essentials of Disaster
Planning
Tener Goodwin Veenema
C H A P T E R
The principles of disaster planning, the common tasks
consistent across all disaster responses, and the key
components of a disaster preparedness plan are
introduced in this chapter. Definitions of the different types
of disasters are provided, along with a classification
system for disasters based on their common and unique
features; onset, duration, and effect (immediate
aftermath); and reactive period. The concept of the
disaster time line as an organizational framework for
strategic planning is introduced. The five areas of focus in
O V E R V I E W
emergency and disaster preparedness—preparedness,
mitigation, response, recovery, and evaluation—are
addressed. Risk assessment, hazard identification and
mapping, and vulnerability analysis are presented as
methods for decision making and planning. The concepts
of disaster epidemiology and measurement of the
magnitude of a disaster’s impact on population health are
explored. Situations suggestive of an increased need for
planning, such as bioterrorism and hazmat (hazardous
material) events, are addressed.
nomic losses associated with these events have placed
an imperative on disaster planning for emergency preparedness. Global warming, shifts in climates, sea-level
rise, and societal factors may coalesce to create future
calamities. Finally, war, acts of aggression, and the incidence of terrorist attacks are reminder of the potentially
deadly consequences of man’s inhumanity toward man.
A review of recent disasters since 2000—political
strife and conflicts in Angola, Afghanistan, Ethiopia,
D.R. Congo, Sudan, Iraq, and Sierra Leone—indicates
that few disasters are the result of a single cause and
INTRODUCTION
Disasters have been integral parts of the human experience since the beginning of time, causing premature
death, impaired quality of life, and altered health status. The risk of a disaster is ubiquitous. On average, one
disaster per week that requires international assistance
occurs somewhere in the world. The recent dramatic increase in natural disasters, their intensity, the number
of people affected by them, and the human and eco-
3
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
4
May 14, 2007
Part I Disaster Preparedness
effect. The disasters unfolding in this century are frequently complex human emergencies associated with
global instability, economic decay, political upheaval
and collapse of government structures, violence and
civil conflicts, famine, and mass population displacements. The Sumatra tsunami and Hurricane Katrina,
as well as the 2004 and 2006 hurricane seasons, point
to more natural disasters and their growing complexity, which create considerable challenges to disaster
planners.
In the United States, nurses constitute the largest
sector of the health care workforce and will certainly be
on the front lines of any emergency response. As part of
the country’s overall plan for disaster preparedness, all
nurses must have a basic understanding of disaster science and the key components of disaster preparedness,
including the following:
(1) The definition and classification system for disasters
and major incidents based on common and unique
features of disasters (onset, duration, effect, and reactive period).
(2) Disaster epidemiology and measurement of the
health consequences of a disaster.
(3) The five areas of focus in emergency and disaster
preparedness: preparedness, mitigation, response,
recovery, and evaluation.
(4) Methods such as risk assessment, hazard identification and mapping, and vulnerability analysis.
(5) Awareness of the role of the nurse in a much larger
response system.
This chapter introduces the reader to the principles of disaster planning, the common tasks consistent
across all disaster responses, and the key components
of a disaster preparedness plan.
DEFINITION AND CLASSIFICATION
OF DISASTERS
Disasters have many definitions. Disaster may be defined as any destructive event that disrupts the normal functioning of a community. Disasters have been
defined as ecologic disruptions, or emergencies, of a
severity and magnitude that result in deaths, injuries,
illness, and property damage that cannot be effectively
managed using routine procedures or resources and that
require outside assistance (Landesman et al., 2001).
Health care providers characterize disasters by what
they do to people—the consequences on health and
health services. A medical disaster is a catastrophic
event that results in causalities that overwhelm the
health care resources in that community (Al-Madhari
& Zeller, 1997). Noji (1997) describes disasters quite
simply, as “events that require extraordinary efforts beyond those needed to respond to everyday emergencies”
(p. 1). Disasters may be classified into two broad categories: natural (those caused by natural or environmental forces) or man-made (human generated). The World
Health Organization defines natural disaster as the “result of an ecological disruption or threat that exceeds
the adjustment capacity of the affected community”
(Lechat, 1979). Natural disasters include earthquakes,
floods, tornadoes, hurricanes, volcanic eruptions, ice
storms, tsunamis, and other geologic or meteorological phenomena. Man-made disasters are those in which
the principal direct causes are identifiable human actions, deliberate or otherwise (Noji, 1996). Man-made
disasters include biological and biochemical terrorism,
chemical spills, radiological (nuclear) events, fire, explosions, transportation accidents, armed conflicts, and
acts of war.
Human-generated disasters can be further divided
into three broad categories: (a) complex emergencies,
(b) technologic disasters, and (c) disasters that are not
caused by natural hazards but occur in human settlements. Complex emergencies involve situations where
populations suffer significant casualties as a result of
war, civil strife, or other political conflict. Some disasters
are the result of a combination of forces such as drought,
famine, disease, and political unrest that displace millions of people from their homes. These humanitarian
disasters can be epic in proportion, such as civilians fleeing the Iraq war or refugees displaced by the conflict in
Darfur. With technologic disasters, large numbers of people, property, community infrastructure, and economic
welfare are directly and adversely affected by major industrial accidents; unplanned release of nuclear energy;
and fires or explosions from hazardous substances such
as fuel, chemicals, or nuclear materials (Noji, 1996).
The distinction between natural and human-generated
disasters may be blurred; a natural disaster, or phenomenon, may trigger a secondary disaster, the result
of weaknesses in the human environment. An example
of this is a chemical plant explosion following an earthquake. Such combinations, or synergistic disasters, are
commonly referred to as NA-TECHs (Natural and Technological Disasters) (Noji, 1996). A NA-TECH disaster
occurred in the former Soviet Union, when windstorms
spread radioactive materials across the country, increasing by almost 50% the land area contaminated in an earlier nuclear disaster. Disasters can and do occur simultaneously (e.g., a chemical attack along with a nuclear
assault), potentiating the death and devastation created
by each.
Disasters are frequently categorized based on their
onset, impact, and duration. For example, earthquakes
and tornadoes are rapid-onset events—short durations
but with a sudden impact on communities. Hurricanes
and volcanic eruptions have a sudden impact on a
community; however, frequently advance warnings are
issued enabling planners to implement evacuation and
early response plans. A bioterrorism attack may be
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
Chapter 1 Essentials of Disaster Planning
sudden and unanticipated and have a sudden and prolonged impact on a community.
In contrast, droughts and famines have a more gradual onset or chronic genesis (the so-called creeping disasters) and generally have a prolonged impact. Factors
that influence the impact of a disaster on a community include the nature of the event, time of day or year,
health and age characteristics of the population affected,
and the availability of resources (Gans, 2001). Further
classification of terms in the field of disaster science
distinguishes between hazards and disasters. Hazards
present the possibility of the occurrence of a disaster
caused by natural phenomena (e.g., hurricane, earthquake), failure of man-made sources of energy (e.g.,
nuclear power plant), or by human activity (e.g., war).
Defining an event as a disaster also depends on the
location in which it occurs, particularly the population
density of that location. For example, an earthquake occurring in a sparsely populated area would not be considered a disaster if no people were injured or affected
by loss of housing or essential services. However, the
occurrence of even a small earthquake could produce
extensive loss of life and property in a densely populated region (such as Los Angeles) or a region with
inadequate construction or limited medical resources.
Similarly, numbers and types of casualties that might
be handled routinely by a large university hospital or
metropolitan medical center could overwhelm a small
community hospital.
Hospitals and other health care facilities may further classify disasters as either “internal” or “external.”
External disasters are those that do not affect the hospital infrastructure but do tax hospital resources due to
numbers of patients or types of injuries (Gans, 2001).
For example, a tornado that produced numerous injuries and deaths in a community would be considered
an external disaster. Internal disasters cause disruption
of normal hospital function due to injuries or deaths
of hospital personnel or damage to the physical plant,
as with a hospital fire, power failure, or chemical spill
(Aghababian, Lewis, Gans, & Curley, 1994). Unfortunately, one type of hospital disaster does not necessarily
preclude the other, and features of both internal and external disasters may be present if a natural phenomenon
affects both the community and the hospital. This was
the case with Hurricane Andrew (1992), which caused
significant destruction in hospitals, in clinics, and in the
surrounding community when it struck south Florida
(Sabatino, 1992), and Hurricane Katrina (2005) when
it impacted the Gulf Coast, rupturing the levee in New
Orleans (Berggren, 2005).
DECLARATION OF A DISASTER
In the United States, the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act, passed by Congress
5
in 1988 and amended in 2000, provides for federal government assistance to state and local governments to
help them manage major disasters and emergencies.
Under the Stafford Act, the president may provide federal resources, medicine, food and other consumables,
work assistance, and financial relief (Stafford Act). On
average, 38 presidential disaster declarations are made
per year; most are made immediately following impact, and review of recent years’ data suggests that the
number of disasters is increasing (see Table 1.1; Federal Emergency Management Agency [FEMA], 2007).
If the consequences of a disaster are clear and imminent and warrant redeployment actions to lessen
1.1
Federally Declared Disasters
1976–2007
YEAR
TOTAL DISASTER DECLARATIONS
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
30
22
25
42
23
15
24
21
34
27
28
23
11
31
38
43
45
32
36
32
75
44
65
50
45
45
49
56
68
48
52
14 (as of March, 2007)
Total
1,193
Average
38
Source: Federal Emergency Management Agency (2007). Retrieved
3/07/07 from http://www.fema.gov/news/disaster totals annual.fema
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
6
May 14, 2007
Part I Disaster Preparedness
Figure 1.1 Billion dollar U.S. weather disasters, 1980–2004—National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
Source: Retrieved from the World Wide Web 5/10/06 at http://www.1.nedc.noaa.gov/pub/data/special/billion2004.pdf
or avert the intensity of the threat, a state’s governor may request assistance even before the disaster
has occurred. A library of all past and current federally declared disasters in the United States can be located at the FEMA Web site (http://www.fema.gov/
library/dizandemer.shtm). A current list of international
declared disasters and emergencies and links to disease
outbreaks can be located on the World Health Organization’s Web site (http://www.who.int/health topics/
disasters/en/).
HEALTH EFFECTS OF DISASTERS
Disasters affect communities and their populations in
different ways. Damaged and collapsed buildings are evidence of physical destruction. Roads, bridges, tunnels,
rail lines, telephone and cable lines, and other transportation and communication links are often destroyed.
Public utilities (e.g., water, gas, electricity, and sewage
disposal) may be disrupted. A substantial percentage of
the population may be rendered homeless and forced to
relocate temporarily or permanently. Disasters damage
and destroy businesses and industry, agriculture, and
the economic foundation of the community. The impact of weather disasters alone has generated costs of
over a billion dollars (see Figure 1.1). The federal government committed $85 billion to recovery efforts for
Hurricane Katrina alone. The health effects of disasters
may be extensive and broad in their distribution across
populations (see chapter 8 for further discussion). In
addition to causing illness and injury, disasters disrupt
access to primary care and preventive services. Depending on the nature and location of the disaster, its effects
on the short- and long-term health of a population may
be difficult to measure.
Epidemiology, as classically defined, is the quantitative study of the distributions and determinants of
health-related events in human populations (Gordis,
2004; see chapter 15 for further discussion). Disaster
epidemiology is the measurement of the adverse health
effects of natural and human-generated disasters and
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
Chapter 1 Essentials of Disaster Planning
the factors that contribute to those effects, with the
overall objective of assessing the needs of disasteraffected populations, matching available resources to
needs, preventing further adverse health effects, evaluating program effectiveness, and planning for contingencies (Lechat, 1990; Noji, 1996). Disasters affect
the health status of a community in the following
ways:
■ Disasters may cause premature deaths, illnesses, and
injuries in the affected community, generally exceeding the capacity of the local health care system.
■ Disasters may destroy the local health care infrastructure, which will therefore be unable to respond to the
emergency. Disruption of routine health care services
and prevention initiatives may lead to long-term consequences in health outcomes in terms of increased
morbidity and mortality.
■ Disasters may create environmental imbalances, increasing the risk of communicable diseases and environmental hazards.
■ Disasters may affect the psychological, emotional,
and social well-being of the population in the affected
community. Depending on the specific nature of the
disaster, responses may range from fear, anxiety, and
depression to widespread panic and terror.
■ Disasters may cause shortages of food and cause severe nutritional deficiencies.
■ Disasters may cause large population movements
(refugees) creating a burden on other health care systems and communities. Displaced populations and
their host communities are at increased risk for communicable diseases and the health consequences of
crowded living conditions. (Noji, 1996)
THE DISASTER CONTINUUM
The life cycle of a disaster is generally referred to as the
disaster continuum, or emergency management cycle.
This life cycle is characterized by three major phases,
preimpact (before), impact (during), and postimpact (after), and provide the foundation for the disaster time
line (Figure 1.2). Specific actions taken during these
three phases, along with the nature and scope of the
planning, will affect the extent of the illness, injury, and
death that occurs.
The five basic phases of a disaster management program include preparedness, mitigation, response, recovery, and evaluation (Kim & Proctor, 2002; Landesman,
2001). There is a degree of overlap across phases, but
each phase has distinct activities associated with it.
Preparedness refers to the proactive planning efforts
designed to structure the disaster response prior to its
occurrence. Disaster planning encompasses evaluating
potential vulnerabilities (assessment of risk) and the
7
propensity for a disaster to occur. Warning (also known
as forecasting) refers to monitoring events to look for
indicators that predict the location, timing, and magnitude of future disasters.
Mitigation includes measures taken to reduce the
harmful effects of a disaster by attempting to limit its
impact on human health, community function, and economic infrastructure. These are all steps that are taken
to lessen the impact of a disaster should one occur and
can be considered as prevention measures. Prevention
refers to a broad range of activities, such as attempts
to prevent a disaster from occurring, and any actions
taken to prevent further disease, disability, or loss of
life. Mitigation usually requires a significant amount of
forethought, planning, and implementation of measures
before the incident occurs.
The response phase is the actual implementation of
the disaster plan. Disaster response, or emergency management, is the organization of activities used to address the event. Traditionally, the emergency management field has organized its activities in sectors, such as
fire, police, hazardous materials management (hazmat),
and emergency medical services. The response phase
focuses primarily on emergency relief: saving lives, providing first aid, minimizing and restoring damaged systems such as communications and transportation, and
providing care and basic life requirements to victims
(food, water, and shelter). Disaster response plans are
most successful if they are clear and specific, simple to
understand, use an incident command system, are routinely practiced, and updated as needed. Response activities need to be continually evaluated and adjusted to
the changing situation.
Recovery actions focus on stabilizing and returning the community (or an organization) to normal (its
preimpact status). This can range from rebuilding damaged buildings and repairing infrastructure, to relocating
populations and instituting mental health interventions.
Rehabilitation and reconstruction involve numerous
activities to counter the long-term effects of the disaster
on the community and future development.
Evaluation is the phase of disaster planning and response that often receives the least attention. After a
disaster, it is essential that evaluations be conducted to
determine what worked, what did not work, and what
specific problems, issues, and challenges were identified. Future disaster planning needs to be based on empirical evidence derived from previous disasters.
DISASTER PLANNING
Effective disaster planning addresses the problems
posed by various potential events, ranging in scale from
mass casualty incidents, such as motor vehicle collisions
with multiple victims, to extensive flooding or earthquake damage, to armed conflicts and acts of terrorism
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
8
May 14, 2007
Part I Disaster Preparedness
Figure 1.2 Disaster nursing timeline.
Copyright Tener Goodwin Veenema, PhD, MPH, MS, CPNP
(Gans, 2001). The disaster-planning continuum is broad
in scope and must address collaboration across agencies and organizations, advance preparations, as well
as needs assessments, event management, and recovery
efforts. Although public attention frequently focuses on
medical casualties, it is imperative to consider numerous other factors when disaster plans and responses are
being designed and developed. Participation by nurses
in all phases of disaster planning is critical to ensure
that nurses are aware of and prepared to deal with whatever these numerous other factors may turn out to be.
Individuals and organizations responsible for disaster
plans should consider all possible eventualities—from
the sanitation needs of crowds at mass gatherings, to the
psychosocial needs of vulnerable populations, to evacuation procedures for buildings and geographic areas—
when designing a detailed response (Leonard, 1991; Parillo, 1995). Completion of the disaster planning process
should result in the production of a comprehensive disaster or “emergency operations plan.”
TYPES OF DISASTER PLANNING
The two major types of disaster plans are those that
take the agent-specific approach and those that use the
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
Chapter 1 Essentials of Disaster Planning
all-hazards approach. Communities that embrace the
agent-specific approach focus their preparedness activities on the most likely threats to occur based on their
geographic location (e.g., hurricanes in Florida). The
all-hazards approach is a conceptual model for disaster preparedness that incorporates disaster management
components that are consistent across all major types
of disaster events to maximize resources, expenditures,
and planning efforts. It has been observed that despite
their differences many disasters share similarities because certain challenges and similar tasks occur repeatedly and predictably. The Department of Homeland
Security’s National Response Plan encourages all communities to prepare for disasters using the all-hazards
approach instead of stand-alone plans, and the agency
published its guidelines for all-hazards preparedness titled Guide for All-Hazards Emergency Operations Planning (1996). These guidelines are helpful in developing
community emergency operations plans.
Problems, issues, and challenges are commonly encountered across several types of disasters (Auf der
Heide, 1996, 2002; Landesman, 2001). Frequently, these
issues and challenges can be effectively addressed in
core preparedness activities and include the following:
1. Communication problems.
2. Triage, transportation, and evacuation problems.
3. Leadership issues.
4. The management, security of, and distribution of
resources at the disaster site.
5. Advance warning systems and the effectiveness of
warning messages.
6. Coordination of search and rescue efforts.
7. Media issues.
8. Effective triage of patients (prioritization for care
and transport of patients).
9. Distribution of patients to hospitals in an equitable
fashion.
10. Patient identification and tracking.
11. Damage or destruction of the health care infrastructure.
12. Management of volunteers, donations, and other
large numbers of resources.
13. Organized improvisational response to the disruption of major systems.
14. Finally, encountering overall resistance (apathy) to
planning efforts. Auf der Heide states, “Interest in
disaster preparedness is proportional to the recency
and magnitude of the last disaster” (1989).
CHALLENGES TO DISASTER PLANNING
Adequate planning can address many of these issues
in advance and even eliminate some as problems in the
9
Figure 1.3 New York, NY, October 5, 2001—The clean-up
operation continues all through the week and weekend, with
thousands of tons having been removed already.
Photo by Andrea Booher/FEMA News Photo. Source: FEMA, 2001
event of future disaster situations. Challenges to address
proactively are discussed next.
Communication, sharing information among organizations and across many people, is a major priority
in any disaster planning initiative. Failure of the communication system may occur in the event of a disaster, as a result of damage to the infrastructure caused
by the disaster, as well as lack of operator familiarity,
excessive demands, inadequate supplies, and lack of
integration with other communications providers and
technologies. Backup communications systems, such as
wireless, hardwire, and cellular telephones, may reduce
the impact of disrupted standard communications, but,
frequently, even advanced technology has been ineffectual during disasters (Garshnek & Burkle, 1999). Alternative ways for the public, as well as health providers,
to get accurate information is critically important. The
9/11 World Trade Center disaster demonstrated the need
for reliable communication systems such as two-way radios and assured backup systems (see Figure 1.3).
A detailed process for the efficient and effective distribution of all types of resources, including supplemental personnel, equipment, and supplies among multiple organizations and the establishment of a security
perimeter around a disaster site should also be included in the plan. Leadership responsibilities and coordination of all rescue efforts (across territories and
jurisdictions) should be worked out in advance of any
event.
Advance warning systems and the use of evacuation from areas of danger save lives and should be included in community disaster response plans whenever
appropriate. Warnings can now be made months in advance, in the case of El Niño, to seconds in advance
of the arrival of earthquake waves at some distance
from the earthquake. Computers are being programmed
to respond to warnings automatically, shutting down
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
10
May 14, 2007
Part I Disaster Preparedness
Figure 1.4 New Orleans, LA, September 9, 2005—Neighborhoods throughout the area remain flooded as a result of Hurricane Katrina. Crews work on areas where there have been
breaks in the levee in order to avoid additional flooding.
Photo by Jocelyn Augustino. Source: FEMA, 2005
or appropriately modifying transportation systems, lifelines, and manufacturing processes. Warnings are becoming much more useful to society as lead time and
reliability are improved and as society devises ways to
respond effectively. Effective dissemination of warnings
provides a way to reduce disaster losses that have been
increasing in the United States as people move into atrisk areas (FEMA, 2000).
A plan for the use of the mass media for the purpose
of disseminating public health messages in the postimpact phase in order to avoid health problems (e.g., water
safety, food contamination) should be developed in advance. Nurses and other disaster responders may need
training in how to interact effectively with the media.
(See chapter 5 for further discussion.)
A comprehensive disaster plan will account for the
effective triage of patients (prioritization for care and
transport of patients) and distribution of patients to hospitals (a coordinated, even distribution of patients to
several hospitals as opposed to delivering most of the
patients to the closest hospital). Review of previous disaster response efforts reveals that patients are frequently
transferred without adequate triage and that patient
distribution to existing health care facilities is often
grossly unequal and uncoordinated (Auf der Heide,
1996, 2002).
Disaster planning must include a community mutual aid plan in the event that the hospital(s), nursing
home(s), or other residential health care facility needs to
be evacuated. Plans for evacuation of health care facilities must be realistic and achievable, and contain sufficient specific detail as to where patients will be relocated
to and who will be there to care for them. Patient evacuation was a major challenge to disaster response efforts
following Hurricane Katrina, and was hampered by the
destruction of all major transportation routes in and out
of the city. Pre-planning for the possibility of the need
to evacuate entire health care facilities must address alternative modes of transportation and include adequate
security measures (see Figure 1.4).
For large-scale disasters involving a broad geographic region, disaster-medical aid-centers may need
to be established and evenly spaced throughout a community. These disaster-medical aid-centers are provided
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
Chapter 1 Essentials of Disaster Planning
11
HAZARD IDENTIFICATION,
VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS,
AND RISK ASSESSMENT
Figure 1.5 New Orleans, LA, August 31, 2005—People walk
through the New Orleans floodwaters to get to higher ground.
New Orleans was under a mandatory evacuation order as a
result of flooding caused by Hurricane Katrina.
Photo by Marty Bahamonde. Source: FEMA, 2005
in addition to existing emergency medical services and
should be set up no more than an hour’s walk from any
location involved in the disaster to ensure maximum accessibility (Schultz, Koenig, & Noji, 1996). Casualty collection points for both patients and health care providers
may also need to be established in large-scale events
(see Figure 1.5). Potential collection points may include
golf courses and shopping malls, or any large expanse of
open land capable of accommodating both ground and
air transport to serve as a staging area (Schultz et al.,
1996).
Information systems need to be identified or developed that will track patients across multiple (and perhaps temporary) settings. Patient tracking during disasters is a major challenge because of lack of registration
at shelters, and hospital communication systems that
do not interface with other hospitals or county health
departments. Family reunification was a major issue
following hurricanes Katrina and Rita, and has persisted as a major challenge to meaningful recovery initiatives.
Hazard identification and mapping, vulnerability analysis, and risk assessment are the three cornerstone methods of data collection for disaster planning (see Table
1.2). The first step in effective disaster planning requires
advance identification of potential problems for the institution or community involved (Gans, 2001). Different
types of disasters are associated with distinct patterns
of illness and injuries, and limited predictions of these
health outcomes can sometimes be made in advance,
with appropriate and adequate data. Hazards are situations or items that create danger and the potential for
the disaster to occur. Hazard identification and analysis
is the method by which planners identify which events
are most likely to affect a community and serves as the
foundation for decision making for prevention, mitigation, and response. Hazards may include items such
as chemicals used by local industry; transportation elements such as subways, airports, and railroad stations;
or collections of large groups of people in areas with
limited access, such as skyscrapers, nursing homes, or
sports stadiums (see Table 1.3). Environmental and meteorological hazards must also be considered, such as
the presence of fault lines and seismic zones and the
seasonal risks posed by blizzards, ice storms, tornadoes,
hurricanes, wildfires, and heat waves. The National Fire
Protection Association’s Technical Committee on Disaster Management issued international codes and standards that require a community’s hazard identification
to include all natural, technological, and human hazards (NFPA, 2004).
Vulnerability is the “state of being vulnerable—
open to attack, hurt, or injury” (Merriam Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, 2002). The disaster planning team
must identify vulnerable groups of people—those at particular risk of injury, death, or loss of property from each
hazard. Vulnerability analysis can provide predictions
of what individuals or groups of individuals are most
likely to be affected, what property is most likely to sustain damage or be destroyed, and what resources will be
available to mitigate the effects of the disaster. Vulnerability analysis should be conducted for each hazard that
is identified and must be regularly updated to accommodate population shifts and changes in the environment
(Landesman, 2001).
Risk assessment is an essential feature of disaster
planning and is in essence a calculation or model of
risk, in which a comprehensive inventory is created
including all existing and potential dangers, the population most likely to be affected by each danger, and
a prediction of the health consequences. Risk analysis
uses the elements of hazard analysis and vulnerability
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
12
May 14, 2007
Part I Disaster Preparedness
1.2
Methods for Data Collection for
Disaster Planning
HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND MAPPING
Hazard identification is used to determine which events are most
likely to affect a community and to make decisions about who or
what to protect as the basis of establishing measures for
prevention, mitigation, and response. Historical data and data
from other sources are collected to identify previous and
potential hazards. Data are then mapped using aerial
photography, satellite imagery, remote sensing, and geographic
information systems.
VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS
Vulnerability analysis is used to determine who is most likely to
be affected, the property most likely to be damaged or destroyed,
and the capacity of the community to deal with the effects of the
disaster. Data are collected regarding the susceptibility of
individuals, property, and the environment to potential hazards in
order to develop prevention strategies. A separate vulnerability
analysis should be conducted for each identified hazard.
RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment uses the results of the hazard identification and
vulnerability analysis to determine the probability of a specified
outcome from a given hazard that affects a community with
known vulnerabilities and coping mechanisms (risk equals
hazard times vulnerability). The probability may be presented as
a numerical range (i.e., 30% to 40% probability) or in relative
terms (i.e., low, moderate, or high risk). Major objectives of risk
assessment include
■ Determining a community’s risk of adverse health effects due
to a specified disaster (i.e., traumatic deaths and injuries following an earthquake)
■ Identifying the major hazards facing the community and their
sources (i.e., earthquakes, floods, industrial accidents)
■ Identifying those sections of the community most likely to be
affected by a particular hazard (i.e., individuals living in or near
flood plains)
■ Determining existing measures and resources that reduce the
impact of a given hazard (i.e., building codes and regulations
for earthquake mitigation)
■ Determining areas that require strengthening to prevent or
mitigate the effects of the hazard
Source: Information obtained from Landesman, L. (2001). Chapter 5: Hazard assessment, vulnerability analysis, risk assessment and rapid health
assessment. In Public health management of disasters: The practice guide.
Washington, DC: American Public Health Association. The author gratefully acknowledges Dr. Linda Landesman and the American Public Health
Association for permission to reproduce this work.
1.3
Hazard Analysis
Natural Events
Drought
Wildfire (e.g., forest, range)
Avalanche
Winter storms/blizzard: Snow, ice, hail
Tsunami
Windstorm/typhoon/cyclone
Hurricane/typhoon/cyclone
Biological event
Heat wave
Extreme cold
Flood or wind-driven water
Earthquake
Volcanic eruption
Tornado
Landslide or mudslide
Dust or sand storm
Lightning storm
Technological events
Hazardous material release
Explosion or fire
Transportation accident (rail, subway, bridge, airplane)
Building or structure collapse
Power or utility failure
Extreme air pollution
Radiological accident (industry, medical, nuclear power plant)
Dam or levee failure
Fuel or resource shortage
Industrial collapse
Communication disruption
Human events
Economic failures
General strikes
Terrorism (e.g., ecological, cyber, nuclear, biological, chemical)
Sabotage, bombs
Hostage situation
Civil unrest
Enemy attack
Arson
Mass hysteria/panic
Special events (mass gatherings, concerts, sporting events,
political gatherings)
8:22
P1: JZP
SVND026C01
SVNF026/Veenema
May 14, 2007
Chapter 1 Essentials of Disaster Planning
analysis to identify groups of people at particular risk
of injury or death from each individual hazard. The calculation of estimated risk (probability estimate) may be
constant over time, or it may vary by time of day, season, or location relative to the community (Gans, 2001).
Risk assessment necessitates the cooperation of corporate, governmental, and community groups to produce a
comprehensive listing of all potential hazards (Leonard,
1991; Waeckerle, 1991).
The following disaster prevention measures can be
implemented following the analysis of hazards, vulnerability, and risk:
■ Prevention or removal of hazard (e.g., closing down
an aging industrial facility that cannot implement
safety regulations).
■ Removal of at-risk populations from the hazard (e.g.,
evacuating populations prior to the impact of a hurricane; resettling communities away from flood-prone
areas).
■ Provision of public information and education (e.g.,
providing information concerning measures that the
public can take to protect themselves during a tornado).
■ Establishment of early warning systems (e.g., using
satellite data about an approaching hurricane for public service announcements).
■ Mitigation of vulnerabilities (e.g., sensors for ventilation systems capable of detecting deviations from
normal conditions; sensors to check food, water, currency, and mail for contamination).
■ Reduction of risk posed by some hazards (e.g., relocating a chemical depot farther away from a school
to reduce the risk that children would be exposed to
hazardous materials; enforcing strict building regulations in an earthquake-prone zone).
■ Enhancement of a local community’s capacity to respond (e.g., health care coordination across the entire health community, including health departments,
hospitals, clinics, and home care agencies).
Regardless of the type of approach used by planners
(agent-specific or all-hazard), all hazards and potential
dangers should be identified before an effective disaster
response can be planned.
CAPACITY TO RESPOND
Resource identification is an essential feature of disaster planning. A community’s capacity to withstand a
disaster is directly related to the type and scope of resources available, the presence of adequate communication systems, the structural integrity of its buildings
and utilities (e.g., water, electricity), and the size and
sophistication of its health care system (Cuny, 1998;
13
Gans, 2001). Resources include both human and physical elements, such as organizations with specialized
personnel and equipment. Disaster preparedness should
include assembling lists of health care facilities; medical, nursing, and emergency responder groups; public works and other civic departments; and volunteer
agencies, along with phone numbers and key contact
personnel for each. Hospitals, clinics, physician offices,
mental health facilities, nursing homes, and home care
agencies must all have the capacity to ensure continuity
of patient care despite damage to utilities, communication systems, or their physical plant. Communication
systems must be put in place so that hospitals, health
departments, and other agencies both locally and regionally, can effectively communicate with each other
and share information about patients in the event of
a disaster. Within hospitals, departments should have
readily available a complete record of all personnel,
including home addresses and home, pager, and cellular phone numbers to ensure access 24 hours a day.
Resource availability will vary with factors such as time
of day, season, and reductions in the workforce. Creativity may be needed in identifying and mobilizing human
resources to ensure an adequate workforce (see Case
Study 1.1). Disaster plans must also include alternative
treatment sites in the event of damage to existing health
care facilities or in order to expand the surge capacity
of the present health care system.
Coordination between agencies is also necessary to
avoid chaos if multiple volunteers respond to the disaster and are not directed and adequately supervised. As
with the 9/11 disaster, many national health care workers and emergency medica…